Abbeville, Louisiana is one place where conservation, regulation, and luxury fashion converge on a workbench. On a recent day at Vermilion Gator Farm, Jacob Sagrera unrolled an alligator skin, brushed off flecks of salt, and graded it under the light for blemishes before moving it into a pile of hides marked with yellow tracking tags. The tags allow authorities to enforce legal trade as skins move to tanneries and products made for fashion runways and shops.

Advocates of commercial alligator farming say the market-based approach has helped protect a species that was once hunted at risk of extinction. Not all conservationists agree, but the program’s supporters argue that tying conservation to revenue gives landowners incentives to maintain wetlands and keep alligators on managed farms rather than disappearing from the landscape.

Louisiana officials and researchers describe American alligators as having recovered in the wild after the species went on the Endangered Species List decades ago, with some experts saying their numbers would rebound further if habitat stayed in place. State agencies, however, proposed a system that would involve farmers collecting eggs, raising the reptiles for meat and skin sales, and releasing some of the animals back into the wild each year.

In the program described by the state, farm output has become a centerpiece of that approach. The Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries produces around 400,000 farmed alligators each year, values farmed skins in 2024 at over $56 million, and uses state data on nest surveys and hunting tags to decide how many young alligators to release annually. The department estimates there are around 3 million alligators in Louisiana today, and it says the share of farmed gators returned each year has fallen from almost 20% in the early 2000s to about 5% now.

The legal framework around the trade also underpins the system’s marketing claims. American alligators were delisted as endangered in 1987 and are listed by the International Union for Conservation of Nature as “Least Concern,” but trade remains regulated because of how closely alligators can resemble other, more vulnerable crocodilian species. Farmers and state officials say the tracking tags help authorities verify that products came from legal operations, and a company that sells alligator leather goods told the program that it keeps records of its own tracking tags to support sourcing disclosures and, when retailers ask, international shipping logs.

Supporters point to how the process can make conservation harder to ignore by attaching value to wetlands and the animals living in them. “These wetlands, these alligators … it has to have some kind of monetary value,” George Melancon, an alligator research biologist for the Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries, said. He said that without money, “Otherwise, people just forget about them.”

Others argue that even regulated farming still carries ethical and conservation risks. Sarah Veatch, principal for wildlife policy for the nonprofit Humane World for Animals, said the economics of the program could help perpetuate illegal commerce: “That shadow trafficking industry is going to be there because you’ve rooted your system in profit.” Veatch added that trade can “normaliz[e]” demand, “legitimize” it and “grow” it.

Luxury brands and industry intermediaries are also involved in the conversation about conservation and sourcing. Christy Gilmore, a consultant who communicates between Louisiana alligator officials and CITES, said brands have taken a more active role in the supply chain by buying into farms, tanneries, and manufacturers. Gilmore said those buyers have pushed beyond basic environmental claims, and she described how her family business became less focused on carbon accounting as luxury customers shifted their questions and due diligence expectations.

As state wildlife officials promote the program, they also finance it. According to the reporting, Louisiana’s agency increased its alligator marketing budget over the years from a cap of $300,000 to $500,000, drawing money from the industry, including sales of hunting tags, and putting it into a dedicated fund for alligator programs. The agency’s alligator program manager, Jeb Linscombe, said the budget rose as the program’s funding increased and as competition grew from hides of other crocodilian species.

The broader fashion landscape has also been shifting in ways the program’s supporters and critics watch closely. Fur farming has declined in recent years, including Poland’s move to end fur farming by the end of 2033 and New York Fashion Week’s decision to ban fur for fall 2026 shows. Some animal rights groups have suggested that exotic skins could be the next target, and smaller venues such as London Fashion Week have already banned exotic skins.

Behind the commercial debate, the alligator program has become a research platform for questions that range from wildlife health to climate effects. Melancon said he wants to better understand alligators’ biology to help ranchers, including developing a vaccine against West Nile virus, which can cause skin lesions that damage hides. Other researchers are examining whether alligators might also be a climate benefit through the wetlands they inhabit, after a study in the journal Scientific Reports found a correlation between alligator abundance and how much carbon a wetland stores.

Chris Murray, an adjunct professor of biology at Southeastern Louisiana University and the lead author of the Scientific Reports study cited in the report, said the research aims to explore whether alligators directly contribute to carbon storage, potentially by eating animals that nibble vegetation that stores carbon. “Alligators can’t stop climate change,” Murray said, but he added there is “the chance they are participating in the global challenge of climate change for the good and not the bad.” He said he is working on the research for conservation generally and not solely to support the industry.

Murray said the goal is to show that alligators have value beyond fashion. “It’s more than just this cool thing for kids to look at,” he said. “It’s, ‘hey, they have an important role in the functionality of the earth that you live in.’”